EcoHealth Report Cards
  • About
  • The Process
  • Contact
  • Report Cards
    • Chesapeake Bay
    • Clinton River
    • Detroit River
    • Guanabara Bay
    • Huron River
    • Lake Erie
    • Long Island Sound
    • Maryland Coastal Bays
    • Orinoco River
    • Rio Grande
    • River Raisin
    • Rouge River
    • Southeast Michigan
    • Sudbury, Assabet, & Concord Rivers
    • Verde River
    • Willamette River

Verde River

  • Home
  • Health
  • Indicators
    • Overall Health Index
    • Base Flow
    • Surfacewater BMPs
    • Groundwater BMPs
    • Water Quality Index
    • Water Quality Certainty
    • Turbidity
    • Macroinvertebrates
    • Upland Condition Index
    • Riparian Birds
    • Fish
    • Recreation Planning
    • Visitor Satisfaction
    • Recreation Access
    • Civic Engagement
    • Digital Engagement
    • Healthcare
    • Education
    • Unemployment
    • Affordable Housing
  • Regions
    • Overall
    • Big and Little Chino
    • Upper Verde
    • Upper Verde Valley
    • Oak Creek
    • Lower Verde Valley
    • Wild and Scenic
    • Lower Verde
  • Issues
  • Publications
  • Take Action
  • About
  1. Home
  2. Report Cards
  3. Verde River
  4. Indicators
  5. Civic Engagement

Civic Engagement

For the river to persist over the long-term the communities who depend on it must be invested in its health. To assess the extent to which local governments are engaging in conversations about water-related issues, we examined the number of times water-related topics appeared in regular meeting minutes of local governments.

How is it scored?

Similar to the digital engagement indicator, we used the occurrence of place names with conservation meaning to indicate engagement. However, in this case, we searched for these terms in meeting minutes collected from the websites of each municipal and county government in the watershed. We also attempted to include Native American Tribes and Nations, but were unable to find a publicly available copy of meeting minutes. 

This indicator used all municipal and county meetings in the Verde River Watershed from 2018 to the time of analysis. Across these documents, we searched for the 29 water-related search terms. We then identified the three highest performing search terms for each government and calculated the mean mention rate across these three terms. After the top three search terms had been scored we compared mention rate of each government to one another using a statistical method called a z-score.  After scoring each government, we aggregated group scores up to the region level by calculating a population-weighted mean. 

In this section

  • Indicators
    • Overall Health Index
    • Base Flow
    • Surfacewater BMPs
    • Groundwater BMPs
    • Water Quality Index
    • Water Quality Certainty
    • Turbidity
    • Macroinvertebrates
    • Upland Condition Index
    • Riparian Birds
    • Fish
    • Recreation Planning
    • Visitor Satisfaction
    • Recreation Access
    • Civic Engagement
    • Digital Engagement
    • Healthcare
    • Education
    • Unemployment
    • Affordable Housing

© 2025 UMCES

  • Home
  • About
  • The Process
  • Contact
  • Report Cards
    • Chesapeake Bay
      • Bay Health
      • Watershed Health
      • Indicators
        • Overall Health Index
        • Dissolved Oxygen
        • Nitrogen
        • Phosphorus
        • Turbidity
        • Water Quality Index
        • Chlorophyll a
        • Water Clarity
        • Conductivity
        • Aquatic Grasses
        • Benthic Community
        • Fish community
        • Temperature Stress
        • Protected Lands
        • Social Index
        • Walkability
        • Heat Vulnerability Index
        • Household income
        • Affordable housing
        • Income equality
        • Jobs growth
      • Bay Regions
        • Lower Eastern Shore
        • Choptank River
        • Upper Eastern Shore
        • Upper Western Shore
        • Patapsco and Back Rivers
        • Lower Western Shore
        • Patuxent River
        • Potomac River
        • Rappahannock River
        • York River
        • James River
        • Elizabeth River
      • Watershed Regions
        • Overall
        • Chemung
        • Choptank
        • Elizabeth
        • Juniata
        • Lower Eastern Shore
        • Lower James
        • Lower Potomac
        • Lower Susquehanna
        • Lower Western Shore
        • Middle James
        • Middle Potomac
        • Middle Susquehanna
        • Patapsco and Back
        • Patuxent
        • Rappahannock
        • Shenandoah
        • Upper Eastern Shore
        • Upper James
        • Upper Potomac
        • Upper Susquehanna
        • Upper Western Shore
        • West Branch Susquehanna
        • York
      • Issues
        • 2024
        • 2023
        • 2022
        • 2021
        • 2020
        • 2019
        • 2018
        • 2017
        • 2016
        • 2015
        • 2014
        • 2013
        • 2012
        • 2011
        • 2010
        • 2009
        • 2008
        • 2007
        • 2006
      • Publications
      • Take Action
      • About
    • Clinton River
      • Health
      • Indicators
        • Overall Health Index
        • Household Income
        • Local Ownership
        • Cost of Flooding
        • Income Equality
        • Trade
        • River Economy
        • Wetlands
        • Tree Cover
        • Forests
        • Fish Populations
        • Bird Diversity
        • Benthic Community
        • Protected Lands
        • Fish Consumption
        • Bacteria
        • Heat Vulnerability
        • Air Quality Index
        • Environmental Justice
        • Flooding
        • Sewer Overflows
        • Impervious Surfaces
        • Farmland
        • Affordable Housing
        • Walkability
        • Parks
        • Beach Access
        • Watercraft Access
        • Fishing
        • Nitrogen
        • Phosphorus
        • Dissolved Oxygen
        • Water Temperature
        • Turbidity
      • Region
        • Clinton River
      • Issues
      • Publications
      • About
    • Detroit River
      • Health
      • Indicators
        • Overall Health Index
        • Household Income
        • Local Ownership
        • Cost of Flooding
        • Income Equality
        • Trade
        • River Economy
        • Wetlands
        • Tree Cover
        • Forests
        • Fish Populations
        • Bird Diversity
        • Benthic Community
        • Protected Lands
        • Fish Consumption
        • Bacteria
        • Heat Vulnerability
        • Air Quality Index
        • Environmental Justice
        • Flooding
        • Sewer Overflows
        • Impervious Surfaces
        • Farmland
        • Affordable Housing
        • Walkability
        • Parks
        • Beach Access
        • Watercraft Access
        • Fishing
        • Nitrogen
        • Phosphorus
        • Dissolved Oxygen
        • Water Temperature
        • Turbidity
      • Region
        • Detroit River Watershed
      • Issues
      • Publications
      • About
    • Guanabara Bay
      • Bay Health
      • Basin Health
      • Indicators
        • Overall Health Index
        • Dissolved Oxygen
        • Biological Oxygen Demand
        • Dissolved Inorganic Nitrogen
        • Total Phosphorus
        • Orthophosphate
        • Turbidity
        • Fecal coliform
      • Sanitation
      • Issues
      • Publications
      • About
    • Huron River
      • Health
      • Indicators
        • Overall Health Index
        • Household Income
        • Local Ownership
        • Cost of Flooding
        • Income Equality
        • Trade
        • River Economy
        • Wetlands
        • Tree Cover
        • Forests
        • Fish Populations
        • Bird Diversity
        • Benthic Community
        • Protected Lands
        • Fish Consumption
        • Bacteria
        • Heat Vulnerability
        • Air Quality Index
        • Environmental Justice
        • Flooding
        • Sewer Overflows
        • Impervious Surfaces
        • Farmland
        • Affordable Housing
        • Walkability
        • Parks
        • Beach Access
        • Watercraft Access
        • Fishing
        • Nitrogen
        • Phosphorus
        • Dissolved Oxygen
        • Water Temperature
        • Turbidity
      • Region
        • Huron River
      • Issues
      • Publications
      • About
    • Lake Erie
      • Lake Health
      • Watershed Health
      • Indicators
        • Overall Health Index
        • Total Phosphorus
        • Dissolved Phosphorus
        • Total Nitrogen
        • Nitrate + Nitrite
        • Chlorophyll a
        • Walleye
        • Yellow Perch
        • Emerald Shiner
        • Bloom Index
        • Source Water Toxin
        • Recreational Toxin
        • Total Suspended Solids
        • Fish
        • Macroinvertebrates
        • Habitat Quality
        • Fish Consumption
        • Pesticide
      • Lake Regions
        • Overall Lake
        • Northwest
        • Southwest
        • Maumee
        • Northeast
        • Eastern Islands
        • Sandusky Bay
      • Watershed Regions
        • Overall Watershed
        • Auglaize
        • Cedar/Portage
        • Detroit
        • Essex
        • Raisin/Huron
        • St. Joseph
        • St. Marys
        • Lower Maumee
        • Lower Thames
        • Sandusky
        • Tiffin
        • Upper Maumee
        • Upper Thames
      • Issues
      • Publications
      • Take Action
      • About
    • Long Island Sound
      • Health
      • Indicators
        • Overall Health Index
        • Dissolved Oxygen
        • Chlorophyll a
        • Water Clarity
        • Dissolved Organic Carbon
      • Regions
        • Overall
        • Western Narrows
        • Eastern Narrows
        • Western Basin
        • Central Basin
        • Eastern Basin
      • Issues
        • 2018
        • 2015
        • 2013
      • Publications
      • Take Action
      • About
    • Maryland Coastal Bays
      • Health
      • Indicators
        • Overall Health Index
        • Chlorophyll a
        • Dissolved Oxygen
        • Nitrogen
        • Phosphorus
        • Seagrass
        • Hard Clams
      • Regions
        • Overall
        • Assawoman Bay
        • Chincoteague Bay
        • Isle of Wight Bay
        • Newport Bay
        • Sinepuxent Bay
        • St. Martin River
      • Issues
        • 2023
        • 2022
        • 2021
        • 2019
        • 2018
        • 2017
        • 2016
        • 2015
      • Publications
      • Take Action
      • About
    • Orinoco River
      • Health
      • Indicators
        • Water Quality Index
        • Risks to Water Quality
        • Water Supply and Demand
        • Natural Land Cover
        • Stable Forest Area
        • Terrestrial Connectivity
        • Fire Frequency
        • Ecosystem Services
        • Human Nutrition
        • Mining in Sensitive Ecosystems
        • River Dolphins
      • Regions
        • Arauca River
        • Atabapo River
        • Bita River
        • Guaviare River
        • Inírida River
        • Matavén River
        • Meta River
        • Tomo River
        • Tuparro River
        • Vichada River
      • Issues
      • Publications
      • About
    • Rio Grande
      • Health
      • Indicators
        • Overall Health Index
        • Annual low flow
        • Zero Flow Days
        • Municipal Water Supply
        • Groundwater
        • Agriculture surface water supply
        • Flow Alteration
        • Riparian Areas
        • Water Supply for Compact
        • Impaired Streams
        • Invasive Trees and Shrubs
        • Wetland Loss
        • Bird Diversity
        • Silvery Minnow
        • Native Fish Diversity
        • All Fish Diversity
        • Native peoples and acequias support
        • Native peoples and acequias representation
        • Water Resource Governance
        • Water Resource Management
        • Protected Lands
        • Fire
        • Park Visitation
        • Recreation Access
        • Cultural and Historical Places
        • Walkability
        • Heat Vulnerability Index
        • Social Vulnerability Index
        • Air Quality
        • Affordable Housing
      • Regions
        • Overall
        • Upper Rio Grande - CO
        • Upper Rio Grande - NM
        • Middle Rio Grande
        • Lower Rio Grande
      • Issues
      • Publications
      • About
    • River Raisin
      • Health
      • Indicators
        • Overall Health Index
        • Household Income
        • Local Ownership
        • Cost of Flooding
        • Income Equality
        • Trade
        • River Economy
        • Wetlands
        • Tree Cover
        • Forests
        • Fish Populations
        • Bird Diversity
        • Benthic Community
        • Protected Lands
        • Fish Consumption
        • Bacteria
        • Heat Vulnerability
        • Air Quality Index
        • Environmental Justice
        • Flooding
        • Sewer Overflows
        • Impervious Surfaces
        • Farmland
        • Affordable Housing
        • Walkability
        • Parks
        • Beach Access
        • Watercraft Access
        • Fishing
        • Nitrogen
        • Phosphorus
        • Dissolved Oxygen
        • Water Temperature
        • Turbidity
      • Region
        • River Raisin
      • Issues
      • Publications
      • About
    • Rouge River
      • Health
      • Indicators
        • Overall Health Index
        • Household Income
        • Local Ownership
        • Cost of Flooding
        • Income Equality
        • Trade
        • River Economy
        • Wetlands
        • Tree Cover
        • Forests
        • Fish Populations
        • Bird Diversity
        • Benthic Community
        • Protected Lands
        • Fish Consumption
        • Bacteria
        • Heat Vulnerability
        • Air Quality Index
        • Environmental Justice
        • Flooding
        • Sewer Overflows
        • Impervious Surfaces
        • Farmland
        • Affordable Housing
        • Walkability
        • Parks
        • Beach Access
        • Watercraft Access
        • Fishing
        • Nitrogen
        • Phosphorus
        • Dissolved Oxygen
        • Water Temperature
        • Turbidity
      • Region
        • Rouge River
      • Issues
      • Publications
      • About
    • Southeast Michigan
      • Health
      • Indicators
        • Overall Health Index
        • Household Income
        • Local Ownership
        • Cost of Flooding
        • Income Equality
        • Trade
        • River Economy
        • Wetlands
        • Tree Cover
        • Forests
        • Fish Populations
        • Bird Diversity
        • Benthic Community
        • Protected Lands
        • Fish Consumption
        • Bacteria
        • Heat Vulnerability
        • Air Quality Index
        • Environmental Justice
        • Flooding
        • Sewer Overflows
        • Impervious Surfaces
        • Farmland
        • Affordable Housing
        • Walkability
        • Parks
        • Beach Access
        • Watercraft Access
        • Fishing
        • Nitrogen
        • Phosphorus
        • Dissolved Oxygen
        • Water Temperature
        • Turbidity
      • Regions
        • Overall
        • Clinton
        • Detroit
        • Huron
        • Raisin
        • Rouge
      • Issues
      • Publications
      • About
    • Sudbury, Assabet, & Concord Rivers
      • Health
      • Indicators
        • Overall
        • Dissolved Oxygen
        • Temperature
        • Suspended Solids
        • Phosphorus
        • Nitrogen
        • Floating Biomass
        • Streamflow Alteration
        • Groundwater Level
        • Summer Streamflow
        • Visual Quality
        • Cultural Importance
        • Impervious Cover
        • Aquatic Connectivity
        • Ecological Integrity
        • Passability
        • Access
        • Trails
        • Bacteria
        • Fish Edibility
      • Regions
        • Upper Sudbury River
        • Lower Sudbury River
        • Upper Assabet River
        • Lower Assabet River
        • Upper Concord River
        • Lower Concord River
      • Issues
      • Publications
      • Take Action
        • Discover your rivers
        • Roll up your sleeves
        • Become a citizen scientist or advocate
        • Celebrate success
      • About
    • Verde River
      • Health
      • Indicators
        • Overall Health Index
        • Base Flow
        • Surfacewater BMPs
        • Groundwater BMPs
        • Water Quality Index
        • Water Quality Certainty
        • Turbidity
        • Macroinvertebrates
        • Upland Condition Index
        • Riparian Birds
        • Fish
        • Recreation Planning
        • Visitor Satisfaction
        • Recreation Access
        • Civic Engagement
        • Digital Engagement
        • Healthcare
        • Education
        • Unemployment
        • Affordable Housing
      • Regions
        • Overall
        • Big and Little Chino
        • Upper Verde
        • Upper Verde Valley
        • Oak Creek
        • Lower Verde Valley
        • Wild and Scenic
        • Lower Verde
      • Issues
      • Publications
      • Take Action
      • About
    • Willamette River
      • Health
      • Indicators
        • Overall Health Index
        • Water Quality Index
        • Toxics
        • Temperature
        • Native Fish
        • Non-native Fish
        • Juvenile Chinook
        • Bald Eagle
        • Channel Complexity
        • Floodplain Forest
        • Flow Targets
        • Peak Flows
        • Fish Consumption Advisories
        • Tribal Fisheries
        • Fecal Bacteria
        • Harmful Algal Blooms
      • Regions
        • Upper Willamette
        • Middle Willamette
        • Lower Willamette
      • Issues
      • Publications
      • Take Action
        • Know your river
        • Make a change
        • Join the movement
        • Celebrate success
      • About