In the middle of the COVID-19 pandemic, a diverse group of stakeholders from around the country assembled over the course of four virtual meetings in the Fall of 2020 to begin the process of developing a report card and scenario model for the Upper Rio Grande watershed. During these workshops, participants discussed potential indicators and methods that could accurately and meaningfully assess the social, economic, ecological, and governmental health of the watershed. This 4-page newsletter summarizes the outputs of this workshop.